best-ever holiday cookie recipe: ethereal brown sugar butter cookies with many variations

Brown Sugar Butter Cookie from The Improvisational Cook

photo: maria robledo

With the holidays soon upon us, I thought I’d post one of my very best cookie recipes. Or perhaps I should say cookie dough recipes: in addition to being able to fashion it into all sorts of cookie shapes and flavors, it also makes a great bake-ahead tart crust. Fleur de Sel Cookies, Earl Grey Tea Cookies, Coffee Vanilla Bean Cookies, Shortbread Pastry Lids and Shells for Tarts, and Brown Sugar Lime Curd Tart are just a few of the creations it easily morphs into. Once you know the basic thinking behind it, you can improvise endlessly with it.

When asked to bring a dessert to a holiday party, I invariably turn to this recipe for delectable, melt-in-your-mouth cookies fragrant with butter and the caramel flavors of light brown sugar. A few drops of orange flower water subtly intensifies the flavor of the butter, a trick I learned from my Greek grandmother.

Never one to write a simple, cut-in-stone recipe, I can’t seem to help writing out ideas for improvising upon a basic approach, with lots of examples. In fact, I wrote a whole book of recipes for improvising, which gives you the tools to do-your-own-thing right away, called The Improvisational Cook. As my holiday gift to you, here’s a PDF from The Improvisational Cook, for Brown Sugar Butter Cookies with Many Improvisations.

Related posts: late night forager: seven layer cake for one
our favorite homemade food gifts to d-i-y
d-i-y food gift: prunes in armagnac (recipe)
homemade food gift: alt-malted milk balls
recipe: dark chocolate cakelets with aromatic pepper and…….

 
leave a Comment
Comments (13)
  1. Anne says:

    Dear Sally,
    Thank you for the holiday PDF! Wishing you glad tidings of joy this holiday season.
    Anne

  2. Sally says:

    Thank you for the lovely message. I hope the cookies bring JOY and inspiration.

  3. Angela Watts says:

    And now to find a way to explain to my husband how orange flower water is something I NEED…..lol

  4. Sally says:

    It is definitely something to have on hand: an essential in baking for sure as it can be a fine subtle boost for any buttery dessert or ones with citrus flavors, It makes for a stunning pecan pie.

  5. Foodelf says:

    Hi Sally, I have only dark demarara sugar – would using it make too much of an impact? I’m wondering if 1/2-1/2 w/white sugar would do it.

    Thanks,

  6. Sally says:

    I might try 2/3 white and 1/3 demarara…Let us know how they come out.

  7. Jenna says:

    I just baked a batch of the brown sugar butter cookies (plain) and a batch with the earl grey. So easy and fabulously delicious! I can’t wait to try more variations…
    Thank you so very much for sharing the recipe!

  8. Sally says:

    Hurray! You’re welcome!

  9. Andrea Raisfeld says:

    LOVE THESE! Finally got around to making them last night. They are so delicate and flavorful and pretty in their simplicity. Thinking of doing a lavender version with lavender sugar and buds mixed in, and another version with salt and rosemary to serve with cheese. Thanks Sally!

  10. Sally says:

    Great minds…I was just thinking of salt chopped with fresh herbes de provence (thyme, rosemary, savory maybe a pinch of lavender) sprinkled on top of the cookie. Let me know what improvisations you come up with.

  11. Donna says:

    I’m hearing all of these rave reviews and I cannot get the original recipe to open. Help, please–I have other sugar sources but now believe I must have this one!

  12. Sally says:

    Hi, I don’t know why you are having difficulty opening the PDF. Perhaps try cutting and pasting this URL directly. http://www.improvisedlife.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/12/Brown-Sugar-Butter-Cookie-Improvs1.pdf Let me know if it works. So glad to hear of rave reviews!

  13. Donna says:

    I’ve got it–thanks so very much! I think I’ll invite friends over for tea and cookies.

Post a Comment